National Guidance Research Forum Promoting evidence-based policy & practice in careers work

Skip to content.

NGRF - UK National Guidance Research Forum

Sections
Note: This site's content is accessible to all versions of every browser. However, this browser may not support basic Web standards, preventing the display of our site's design details. We support the mission of the Web Standards Project in the campaign encouraging users to upgrade their browsers.


Blog Entry [details and replies]

Guidance Community Discussion Space :: helping build careers Weblog 122 entries 08-July-2008 36 authors
show or hide details for this item Can we learn from other professions? Blog Entry 0 replies1 resource 01-September-2004 Lucy Marris
Kind:
Blog Entry
Created:
01-September-2004 20:14:38
Last Updated:
Never Modified
Author:
Lucy Marris
Status:
visible

Resources and Links:

What can be learned from other disciplines? What can be learned from other disciplines? [ Go there ]
The guidance profession is not alone in having to regularly evaluate the effectiveness of its provision. This a common feature for all organisations providing services and this section explores two areas of potential comparison, the medical profession and research done by the Research Centre for Museums and Galleries. It provides access to a briefing which defines and compares impact analysis and evidence-based practice and to a discussion related to this.
I recall the following contribution being made, but I can't remember who by, but the observation seems pertinent... When a patient "gets better" following treatment, how do we know he/she wouldn't have recovered any way, by a process of self-healing; and if "getting better" really was linked...

I recall the following contribution being made, but I can't remember who by, but the observation seems pertinent...

When a patient "gets better" following treatment, how do we know he/she wouldn't have recovered any way, by a process of self-healing; and if "getting better" really was linked to the intervention, how do we know that it was the direct effect of the treatment itself rather than the psychology of the placebo effect?

If the research complexities facing disciplines involved in human interaction are similar, then so too are many of the methodological solutions, or attempted solutions.

Are comparisons valid and could they help us arrive at new and more effective impact methodologies, or at least a better understanding of the issues involved? Or could it be a bit of a wild goose chase?

There is much to be learnt from our colleagues in the Museums and Libraries sector. Inspiring Learning for All, which asked museums, archives and libraries to look beyond the formal learning context and to assess the impact they have on their informal learners and visitors.

Comments please

Please Log in

Username

Password

Title
Lead-in
Body Text ( HTML tags are allowed )
Preview your comment